Cardiff City’s biggest strength has now become the topic of fiercest debate among fans
Bluebirds supporters are torn over one particular selection headache and how best to solve the issue
It has been a pretty positive few months for Cardiff City fans, to say the least. A nigh-on perfect transfer window, a new academy complex, financial troubles seemingly ironing themselves and, of course, good results on the pitch.
As the Bluebirds head into the international break, they sit in eighth position in the Championship table: just one point off the play-offs and three points off third place. It’s positively nosebleed territory for a team which has spent two consecutive seasons battling against the alarming worry of relegation.
Erol Bulut has come in and done an excellent job so far. He has his team well drilled, scoring goals and becoming increasingly more miserly in defence.
READ MORE: Cardiff City news as star admits having ‘tough few weeks’ and Bulut reveals
Bulut placed a large focus on upping the club’s goal output this summer and they have delivered on that front. The transfer strategy was centred around adding goals and creativity and both boxes have been ticked – although it could be argued they are a top-class striker short if they have designs on sustaining this run towards the back end of the season.
Ahead of this campaign, supporters were purring over one position in particular – and it had been a problem position for Cardiff for some time. The lack of playmaker or attack orchestrator had hampered the Bluebirds in recent seasons, with the likes of Lee Tomlin and Harry Wilson a distant memory.
But, heading into the campaign, Cardiff boasted the likes of Aaron Ramsey, Callum Robinson and Rubin Colwill in that position, all vying for the No. 10 slot. Ramsey was sensational at the beginning of the season, pulling the strings and even getting on the score sheet – he netted three times in six games.
However, a rupture of his ACL has rendered him unavailable for the next two months minimum, which would be a major blow to any side at this level. But given the strength in depth mentioned above, that is now less of a problem than what it would have been in years gone by.
Bulut, though, has seen it differently. We were told of the manager’s pragmatic approach before his arrival, with Mehmet Dalman even saying that he does not lose games – if his sides don’t win they get a point, that was the thrust of the conversation. But until now we’ve seen the opposite, really. Cardiff were free-flowing, free-scoring and a little bit haphazard at the back, not really what City fans expected.
Perhaps we have seen what is more akin to a Bulut team in recent weeks since the Ramsey injury, though. The manager shored up the defence and made the midfield more robust, with the inclusion of Ryan Wintle over the likes of Robinson and Colwill.
It has sparked the fiercest debate yet among City supporters. Perhaps away from home or against teams who dominate, there is merit in that decision. But at home to Coventry City, Rotherham United and a struggling Watford team, for example, Cardiff fans were urging the manager to go more offensive. As it happens, City won two and drew one of those games, so perhaps Bulut was proven right in some respects.
But that final game before the break, against the Hornets, was a tired performance and smacked of a team which needed a freshen up or an injection of creativity in lieu of Ramsey. But when asked why he did not opt for Robinson or Colwill against Watford, Bulut offered a cogent response.
“I have a good reason,” he said. “If you see the game, of course I would like to play with two No. 10s. I didn’t use Rubin in the game because we didn’t want to lose more than two points.
“Defensively, Rubin is not at that level where I want to see him. I told him this. Football is not only offensive, if you lose the ball you also have to be defensive. Because of that, Wints was playing in that position and we can have more support in the defence.
“Because the game, we didn’t control it, we didn’t have enough possession. That’s why I put [Romaine] Sawyers on, so that we can keep the ball a little bit with him. That’s why Rubin didn’t play.”
WHATSAPP: For the latest Bluebirds stories delivered straight to your phone, join the Cardiff City WhatsApp here
Robinson has had his injury struggles this season, so perhaps hasn’t really shown what all City fans know he is capable of. Colwill, meanwhile, is arguably in the form of his life, but is still not meeting the defensive requirements of his manager. It appears Bulut thinks he doesn’t add enough offensively to counter what he detracts from the team defensively.
Since the summer, Colwill has six goals and three assists for club and country, albeit in the under-21s at international level, which is as good a return as he has enjoyed in his career to date. Indeed, few people in Cardiff’s entire squad boast those numbers. But, clearly, Bulut believes the 21-year-old must improve in more aspects of his game if he is to be trusted from the off.
